Gay people have been accused of being unfit parents, more likely to
be pedophiles, unable to sustain lasting relationships, and worse. But
research shows these and other myths just aren't based in fact.
Gay parents aren't as good as a father and a mother.
Many of those who oppose gay marriage and gay adoption charge that
same-sex parents aren't good for kids, and that a child needs both a
father and a mother to grow up to be a healthy adult. Research, however,
shows that children of gay parents tend to fare just fine.
For example, one recent study looked at nearly 90 teens, half living
with female same-sex couples and the others with heterosexual couples,
showing that both groups fared similarly in school. Teen boys in
same-sex households had grade point averages of about 2.9, compared with
2.65 for their counterparts in heterosexual homes. Teen girls showed
similar results, with a 2.8 for same-sex households and 2.9 for girls in
Another study found that kids with two moms or two dads were no more
likely than their counterparts in "traditional" homes to engage in
delinquent activities, such as damaging others' property, shoplifting
and getting into fights.
"The bottom line is that the science shows that children raised by
two same-gender parents do as well on average as children raised by two
different-gender parents," said Timothy Biblarz, a sociologist at the
University of Southern California. "This is obviously inconsistent with
the widespread claim that children must be raised by a mother and a
father to do well."
Both studies were described in a literature review paper published in
February 2010 in the Journal of Marriage and Family.
Gay relationships don't last.
Another stereotype is that gay relationships aren't as real or
long-lasting as heterosexual ones.
Research has found that to be untrue. Long-term studies of gay couples indicate that their relationships are just as stable as
"There is considerable evidence that both lesbians and gay men want
to be in strong, committed relationships [and] are successful in
creating these partnerships, despite difficulties created by social
prejudice, stigma, and the lack of legal recognition for same-sex
relationships in most parts of the U.S.," said UCLA psychologist Anne
Peplau, co-author of a book chapter on the subject published in the 2007
Annual Review of Psychology.
For example, John Gottman, a University of Washington emeritus
professor of psychology, and his colleagues collected data from
homosexual couples across 12 years, and found that about 20 percent had
broken up over that time. That rate projected over a 40-year period is
slightly lower than the divorce rate for first marriages among
heterosexual couples over the same time span, according to the study
published in 2003 in the Journal of Homosexuality.
"The overall implication of this research is that we have to shake
off all of the stereotypes of homosexual relationships and have more
respect for them as committed relationships," Gottman said.
In fact, the same study found that gay couples tend to be better at resolving conflict and encouraging positive emotions.
Being gay is a choice.
While some claim that being gay is a choice, or that homosexuality
can be cured, evidence is mounting that same-sex attraction is at least
partly genetic and biologically based.
To test whether genes play a role, researchers have compared
identical twins (in which all genes are shared) to fraternal twins (in
which about 50 percent of genes are shared). A 2001 review of such twin
studies reported that almost all found identical twins were
significantly more likely to share a sexual orientation ? that is, to be
either both gay, or both straight ? than fraternal twins, who are less
genetically close. Such findings indicate that genes do factor into a
Other studies have found that biological effects, such as hormone
exposure in the womb, can also play a role in shaping sexuality. And findings of physiological differences, such
as different inner ear shapes between homosexual and heterosexual
women, contribute to this idea.
"The results support the theory that differences in the central
nervous system exist between homosexual and heterosexual individuals and
that the differences are possibly related to early factors in brain
development," said Sandra Witelson of McMaster University in Ontario, an
author on the 1998 inner ear finding published in the journal
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Most pedophiles are gay.
An especially pernicious myth is that most adults who sexually abuse
children are gay. A number of researchers have looked at this question
to determine if homosexuals are more likely to be pedophiles
than heterosexuals, and the data indicate that's not the case.
For example, in a 1989 study led by Kurt Freund of the Clarke
Institute of Psychiatry in Canada, scientists showed pictures of
children to adult gay and straight males, and measured sexual arousal.
Homosexual men reacted no more strongly to pictures of male children
than heterosexual men reacted to pictures of female children.
A 1994 study, led by Carole Jenny of the University of Colorado
Health Sciences Center, surveyed 269 cases of children who were sexually
molested by adults. In 82 percent of cases, the allegedoffender
was a heterosexual partner of a close relative of thechild,
the researchers reported in the journal Pediatrics. In only two
out of 269 cases, the offender was identified asbeing gay or
"The empirical research does not show that gay or bisexual men
are any more likely than heterosexual men to molest children," wrote
Gregory M. Herek, a professor of psychology at the University of
California at Davis, on his website. Herek, who was not involved in the
1989 or 1994 studies, compiled a review of research on the topic.
Animals are all straight.
Despite a popular perception that male-female pairings are the only
"natural" way, the animal kingdom is actually full of examples of
same-sex couples. Penguins, dolphins, bison, swans, giraffes and
chimpanzees are just a few of the many species that sometimes pair up
with same-sex partners.
Researchers are still mulling over the evolutionary reason, if any,
for gay animal sex, since it doesn't produce offspring. Some ideas are that
it helps strengthen social bonds or encourages some individuals to
focus their resources on nurturing their nieces and nephews, thus boosting their own genes indirectly.
Or, it may simply be fun. "Not every sexual act has a reproductive
function," said Janet Mann, a biologist at Georgetown University.